Showing posts with label Canadian news. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Canadian news. Show all posts

Sunday, November 30, 2008


WINNIPEG LOCAL NEWS:
PARKING, PRISONS AND PASHTUNS:
Ok, here's our quiz section. What do the above 3Ps have in common ? Full marks and a Molly No-Prize to those who guessed that they are indeed a P3, public private partnership, in the guise of the City of Winnipeg's latest decision to award its parking bylaw enforcement to the Anglo-Dutch G4S company. Who exactly are these people ? They claim to employ over 500,000 people worldwide in over 100 countries- just a tad shy of Winnipeg's total population. As the article below makes clear they have made a mess of managing prisons and other services in the UK. They have also been involved in many scandals involving labour rights. For an overview see the Wikipedia article on them as well as an article in the business section of the London Times. They are also, of course, involved in providing services to the occupation forces in Iraq and Afghanistan(can we say mercenaries?). So watch out for the helicopter gunships if you don't pay your ticket on time, and never, never, never plan a wedding party unless you are fully paid up (the bride wore napalm ???). According to the Wikipedia article the anarcho-punk band Crass once wrote a song about these people- though Molly was unable to verify this from the Wiki.
Anyways, here's an article on this takeover here in Winnipeg from Policy Alternatives via the Public Values website. Gotta hand it to Slick Sammy, our beloved comrade leader mayor, his belief in the free market is almost as religiously pure as that of Sneaky Stevie, our beloved comrade leader Prime Minister.
.............................
From British prisons to Winnipeg parking police:
What the 'Peg could learn from Keystone Capers of other governments who rushed out to privatize
.
by Pete Hudson, CCPA Manitoba
November 20, 2008 — Last week it was reported that the Winnipeg Parking Authority has contracted with a company called G4S to hand out parking tickets to meter violators. This tiny portion of the total city budget is worth bothering with because it is illustrative of some serious flaws in the contracting ideology.

Two issues to be considered in relation to contracting out of services traditionally performed by city staff are why and with whom. In relation to the first question, many governments which rushed to contract out public services as part of a more general program of privatization are having second thoughts.

For example, the UK government has recently rescinded the compulsory contracting legislation of its predecessor. It has halted, and pledged to reverse, contracting out of cleaning, laundry and food services in hospitals because of the alarming rise in infections. Closer to home, Toronto has just taken back its garbage collection from private contractors, Port Moody its recycling and solid waste disposal, and Hamilton its water system maintenance because these jurisdictions found it more cost-effective to deliver these in-house, as well as easier to control quality.

A recent study of 100 so-called P3's (a way to contract out financing of public capital projects) found huge cost overruns, failures to meet deadlines, lengthy legal battles, contractors walking away from half finished projects, and outright fraud. Several Canadian jurisdictions, earlier embracing P3's, are now backing away from them; most recently Saskatchewan. Generally speaking the evidence is piling up that the claims of greater efficiencies and better quality are not justified.

So why would the City of Winnipeg persist in its present course of contracting out? Why deny the evidence? The reason seems to be that Mayor Katz and his inner circle, have heard the mantras of "privatization is good", "government is the problem and the market is the solution" so repeatedly deafeningly, that it simply has become a self-evident truth.

This mantra continues to be chanted by the Chamber of Commerce and surfaces in such C of C inspired documents as the Report of the Economic Opportunities Commission, which recommended yet more contracting out for the City, claiming cost savings based on nothing more than faith. In the case of parking meter surveillance, for many years the contract had been awarded to the non-profit Canadian Corps of Commissionaires. This was terminated sometime this year, apparently because of some compliance issues.

This would have been a golden opportunity to ask if it would be more cost-effective to contract in the service to City hired staff. How many workers would be needed to perform the service in-house? What would a union wage and benefits for these workers cost? How might that compare with the contract awarded to G4S costing $2.03m? I don't know the answer to these questions. The point is they were never asked. It is simply taken for granted that contracting out is the way to go.

In regard to the second issue, G4S is a UK-based multinational claiming nearly 500,000 employees worldwide. In 1994, the Home Office contracted out construction, maintenance, and daily running of several prisons to G4S. Among other difficulties, there were almost daily episodes of inmates hopping over the walls. Later there were several incidents of cash-carrying vans operated by G4S going missing. A locked facility to detain asylum seekers experienced a disastrous fire in 2002.

G4S claims that it has learned some lessons since, but the saga has continued. A series of thefts of computers in Nashville and the more astonishing theft of transit buses in Miami Dade County in 2008 has been attributed to lax security provided by G4S. There have been instances of fraud, mostly involving billing for shifts which never occurred, but also other corner cutting practices, as evidenced by complaints about poor food and diet, health care and sanitation, in addition to alleged punitive and undignified treatment of the residents in locked facilities.

Contracting out has usually resulted in much reduced remuneration for workers even when there has been no cost saving to taxpayers — and G4S appears to be yet another case in point. In 2005 representatives of G4S workers from four continents staged a massive protest at the G4S annual general meeting, accusing it of driving down wages and conditions and denying workers basic rights in the countries in which it operates.

G4S had vigorously opposed attempts at unionization of many of its workplaces, and was currently at that time embroiled in dozens of claims of violations of US labour laws. Enforced month-to-month contracts which denied workers access to benefits was said to be commonplace. Regardless of geography and regardless of the presence or absence of a union (organizing efforts have been successful in some G4S workplaces), G4S has experienced, and continues to experience, an unusually high incidence of labour-management strife.

Right from the start of the contracting out craze, critics were questioning the logic behind it. Now that the theory has been empirically tested and found wanting in so many cases, it is difficult to see how the contract between the WPA and G4S will deliver a less costly and better quality service than if delivered by WPA staff. It is, of course, possible. The point is, we will never know, because the questions that need to be asked are so rarely asked at the current Winnipeg City Hall. When they are asked, the questioners are faced with attacks upon their intelligence and their credentials.

We all still hope that if G4S is found wanting, or when the contract expires, whichever comes first, any evaluation would include the possibility of the alternative of contracting in — as should be the case with all such contracts. In the meantime, when I see the new parking police in their "customer friendly" uniforms, handing out tickets one minute and being "ambassadors" for the City the next, I will find it difficult not to think of a good portion of the UK prison population enjoying the delights of the English countryside from the other side of the wall. If you get a ticket, check it twice.

Pete Hudson is Professor Emeritus at the University of Manitoba and a Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives Manitoba research associate.

Thursday, October 16, 2008


CANADIAN POLITICS-BRITISH COLUMBIA:
HOMELESS WIN VICTORY IN VICTORIA BC:
Homelessness has been a growing problem in Canada, and it is likely to worsen as tougher economic times take hold. The usual response of civil authorities nationwide has been to make the problem as invisible as possible, to sweep the homeless under the carpet. Out BC way the homeless have won a court challenge against the Victoria BC bylaw that prevented them from erecting tents in public places. See THIS ARTICLE from the BC ATV News on the reaction of city authorities and the local Chamber of Commerce to the BC Supreme Court decision two days ago that struck down the city bylaw in question.
Homeless people responded rapidly to the decision, and as of yesterday a tent city has sprung up in the 'Mayor's Grove' section of Victoria's Beacon Hill Park. The story from The Hook follows below. For further info on the situation of the homeless in Canada see the Homeless Nation website.
...............................
Tents erected in Victoria as Vancouver lawyers consider ruling:
By Andrew MacLeod
Eight tents stood together in the Mayors' Grove of trees in Victoria's picturesque Beacon Hill Park this morning as people across the province digested the court decision that struck down the city's anti-camping bylaws.

“It's a really important decision,” said Laura Track, a lawyer working on Pivot Legal Society's housing campaign in Vancouver. Pivot has a similar case pending, she said, but hopes Vancouver city hall will learn from the Victoria case.

“In light of this decision we'd like to ask the city if it makes sense to proceed with going to trial,” she said. “We hope this judgment will help them to see things more clearly.”

The Victoria decision rested on the fact there are way more people homeless than there are available emergency shelter beds. “To me I can't see what difference they're going to point to between Vancouver and Victoria,” said Track. Vancouver has about 700 shelter beds for 1,600 homeless people, she said. “We think the legal analysis would be identical here in Vancouver.”
David Arthur Johnston, who has been in and out of jail over the past few years as he's fought for the right to sleep in public places, characterized the time since the court decision came down as “24 hours of anarchy.”

Johnston, rubbing his hands together in the morning cold, said the campers will likely build a kitchen today and may soon make a fire pit for warmth. They have a portable toilet, he said, and the city may also provide facilities.

A bylaw enforcement officer paid a cordial visit to the tent sites this morning, but did not write any tickets. Police officers drove by, one said “good morning” through a loudspeaker, but did not stop.

Victoria Mayor Alan Lowe said yesterday that tent cities will not be allowed as they attract crime. He also blamed the federal and provincial governments for their failure to provide housing. “This judgment demonstrates what years of cuts to social programming and housing programs has done,” he said.

The province's housing and social development minister, Rich Coleman, is yet to make a statement on the ruling. He was unavailable yesterday and remained unavailable today.
“The judge just told the city it's been acting criminally as long as it's had those bylaws,” Johnston said, adding the police are welcome to enforce laws against criminal activity. “If they want to deal with it on a tent by tent basis, let them. If somebody's going to deal crack out of their tent they invite their own karma.”

Despite the weather, he predicted homeless people will erect more tents in the region. “A lot of people are just getting used to the information. Not everyone wants to live in a tent city.”

Andrew MacLeod is The Tyee's Legislative Bureau Chief in Victoria. You can reach him here.

Monday, August 11, 2008



CANADIAN NEWS:

ANTI-POLICE RIOT IN MONTREAL:


What happened in Montréal-Nord last Saturday night is a matter of some dispute. Police claim that up to 20 youths surrounded a pair of officers and charged them when they attempted to arrest a local youth Fredy Villenueva. One (or more ?) of the officers discharged their guns, killing Villenueva and seriously injuring two others. Reports have differed as to which of the officers shot first. Other eyewitness reports have said that there were far fewer people involved in the original confrontation with the police, perhaps about 6. The investigation of the incident is now in the hands of the Sûreté Du Québec, the provincial police force, and things may or may not be clarified in the future.








What is not in doubt is what happened the other evening, as a demonstration protesting what many residents of Montréal-Nord feel is racial profiling on the part of the police turned into a full fledged riot as police and local youths played a cat and mouse game through the streets of the neighbourhood, with the youths having the home field advantage. In the end one police officer was shot, about 20 stores were looted and several city vehicles, both police and otherwise were burnt. Hundreds of police were dispatched to the neighbourhood to attempt to control the riot.








In the wake of these events numerous and sundry government officials in Québec, from the mayor of Montréal to Sylvie Roy, public security critic for the opposition Action democratique du Québec , jumped on a "law and order" bandwagon, saying that "this sort of thing will not be tolerated". The government of the province and the spokesmen for the Montréal police appeared to take a softer line, saying that the original shooting will "be investigated", appealing for calm, and saying that the Montreal police force is "trying" to improve its relations with minority communities. The police, however, had to throw in the old canard about "outside agitators" ie "criminals who came from outside of the community" to participate in the riot. Yup, there were indeed lots of "outsiders" fighting in the streets of Montréal-Nord yesterday evening, and the vast majority of them wore City of Montréal uniforms.





A TALE OF TWO CITIES:


Montréal-Nord is an impoverished(in parts) community of about 84,000 people with a street gang problem, though hardly of the magnitude of cities out here in the west of Canada. About 25% of the area's population are immigrants (larger than that of the poorer West End of Winnipeg, but perhaps comparable to some more affluent areas of this city where Filipinos and South Asians settle), and about 15% are black and 3.5% latino. The first thing that strikes me on reading such numbers is how small they seem compared to some of Winnipeg's neighbourhoods which are far more than 15% aboriginal.








The comparison is especially apt as two aboriginal men have been killed by police here in Winnipeg, two in as many weeks. One by taser and one by gunshot. One of the deceased was the nephew of J.J. Harper, an innocent aboriginal man who was gunned down many years ago and whose death led to a major inquiry into police/aboriginal relations in this city. Most of the recommendations of that inquiry remain unimplemented over a decade after it delivered its report.








There is certainly a lot of bitterness amongst aboriginals in this city over the two recent deaths, but the whole idea of "rioting" is pretty well a non-starter here. For one thing the victims here in Winnipeg were nowhere near as clearly innocent of any crime as the victim in Montréal. But the contrast goes deeper than that. Montréal has what one might term "a culture of riot". That city may account for a clear majority of the riots in the whole of Canada that have occurred over the past few decades. Very few of these were racially based. In the last year alone a demonstration against police brutality ended in a riot in March when the police did exactly what they were accused of and attacked. In April we had the latest (of several ?) "hockey riots" after the Canadiens beat the Boston Bruins in the NFL semi-final. What would have happened if they had lost ?








There are undoubtedly many reasons for this. People are far more "concentrated" in Montréal than out here.I personally don't like the "cramped" feeling, but this has its good points. It means that Montréal has a far more vibrant "street life" than a city like Winnipeg does. This, in turn, means that Montréal is a far safer city than any in western Canada. Too many eyes on the street. If a population is concentrated it not only looks after itself but is also much more likely to "fight back" when it feels it is threatened, as many minorities in Montréal feel they are by the police. As well, Québec culture, in general and not just its minorities, is far less "deferent to authority" than that of the rest of Canada(and North America).The minorities take their cue from the majority. This is what makes that province perhaps the most interesting place on the continent. To a large extent the aboriginal population here in the west have yet to develop the idea of "fighting back" in a collective sense outside of the Rez. Not that such fighting back hasn't been growing,and not that it isn't fully justified, but it is far too much a individualist manner, often self-destructive, in which such fighting back occurs.





REPORTS FROM THE GROUND:


The ROC (Rest of Canada) will be flooded with mass media perspectives on the riots in the next few days. Here are a couple of perspectives that won't appear in your daily newspapers, both translations from platformist comrades in the province of Québec. The original French versions are available at the websites mentioned. First of all from La Commune, the website of the Montréal NEFAC(North Eastern Federation of Anarchist Communists).


....................................



Montreal North: Fire and Blood:


Montreal-Nord has been the site of violent clashes between police and many young people in the neighbourhood last night, the day after the murder of a district youth, 18 years of age, by a police officer.








Friday evening, Dany Villanueva was playing dice with some friends in a local park when he was stopped by a policeman patrolling nearby. After a few exchanges of insults, young people are probably too used to be harassed by the cops, the officer threw himself on Villanueva and began to punch him out. At this point, his brother and a friend Fredy interposed and try to restrain the officer. Reaction: four shot were fired at the youths, killing one person, Fredy Villanueva and two others were wounded.








While the police reported a veritable encirclement and weapons that the young people "possibly" had in their possession, many witnesses of the scene say that police were solely responsible for the incident and that the initial reaction that followed was totally disproportionate. Following the tragedy, no weapons were found on the youths. (Here in Winnipeg there is still some dispute about one of the killings as to whether the victim was armed with a knife or with a cellphone!!!!)








Twenty-four hours later, the anger erupts in the streets. A spontaneous demonstration turns to riot and police are deployed in force throughout the neighborhood. But this is not gratuitous violence: all the reports of the events (even the most reactionary) indicate that there is a widespread resentment against the police who expressed themselves the previous night.








"It is calm," police are crying today, of course. What they expect, this band of dangerous idiots ,that they can kill (once again) one of us with impunity and without consequences?


.....................................


And then from the Voix de faits blog in Québec City, another group of NEFAC.


...................................

HORRIBLE DAY/TORRID NIGHT:
As everyone knows today, yesterday (10/08/08), in the North Terminal area (known by the police as Montréal Noir (Black Montreal), as they say Côtes des Négres instead of Côte des Neiges"(Black Coast rather than Snow Coast-Molly), a zealous cop lacking nuanced skill in his work has seen fit to fire on youths who were hanging out in the streets.
First lie: "there were about twenty who decided to attack our officers"-Said the spokesman for the SPVM(Montréal police-Molly).
First truth: an 18 year old youth no longer sees the sunset, nor breath in the smells of his neighbourhood nor anything else.
Second truth: There were about 6 young people and they probably weren't a threat to the ants on the pavement. Evil cellphones that can take videos, they constantly make liars out of the cops. ...


On the evening that followed the assassination, an event that the media described as peaceful (you certainly know that hackneyed term which means "not dangerous") turned to a riot. On this point, it is not necessary to blame the journalists too much since they / say they are talking to the camera to someone who must three messages in thirty seconds. Any longer and you lose the audience and that is not good for the station. However, this event was not peaceful at all.


Imagine you live in a neighborhood that lives constantly under high arrogant police presence . Imagine then that one of your own is brutally murdered in the street by the police and their mafia their uses of media to disseminate lies. Finally, the goddamn cell phone videos make you see the truth. If you're not angry, you are not right in the head.


So from that standpoint it is necessary to analyse the acts of yesterday evening. First, a murderous policeman. Secondly, a lying policeman. Thirdly, the event filled with angry people who see the fellows of the assassins before it. The final was easy to predict, but, with the brains of chickens, SPVM did not see coming.


What will happen tonight?

Friday, December 07, 2007


CANADIAN JUSTICE ?
ROBERT LATIMER DENIED DAY PAROLE:
There are some things that come across on the news that are really and truly anger-provoking. The latest that Molly has seen is the decision of the National Parole Board who, in their wisdom (sic), have decided to deny day parole to Robert Latimer after he had served 7 years of his 2nd degree murder conviction for killing his severely disabled daughter Tracy Latimer. Mr. Latimer will not have the opportunity to apply for parole again for another two years. Tracy suffered from cerebral palsy due to a difficult birth. This was perhaps the least of her problems. She also suffered from severe scoliosis, epilepsy, quadriplegia and chronic vomiting. her medical condition was such that most of the doctors involved in her case felt that they could not advance treatment for her chronic excruciating pain beyond liquid Tylenol. She also had severe difficulty in swallowing.
Now Molly has lots of "ins" on this one. First of all, she is a veterinarian, and she knows the old medical adage about what to do when confronted by an obviously intractable medical problem. The saying goes..."refer the bastard". It's a variation of the everyday-life method of making something become somebody else's problem. Tracy was "referred" repeatedly in her short life to surgeons who were fully confident in their techniques, and repeated cutting and chopping did nothing nut make her pain worse. There's a second "in" here as Molly has a grand-nephew who also suffers from cerebral palsy because of a difficult birth. The difference is that he is not in screaming unremitting pain 24/7. He is institutionalized, but his life is tolerable, and the family has given him and his mother, my niece, the maximum possible support. Latimer's case was very different. Every medical intervention seemed to make Tracy worse and worse. For readers of this blog from outside of Canada (and some in this country) I refer them to the Robert Latimer. Net site for Latimer's own story and also to the Wikipedia article on the case for the full story from a disinterested viewpoint. My last "in" on this situation I will leave for later in this blog, but it should be apparent from what I have said above that I am not "unfamiliar" with the matters involved in this case.
The denial of Latimer's parole has sparked incredible outrage from a vast segment of the Canadian population. In the original trial the jury was ignorant of the legal fact of "jury supremacy" ie that a jury can rule for acquittal despite the obvious guilt of the accused. This "residue of real justice" is part of our common-law heritage, and remains part of it so that common sense can overrule legal formalities. Mr. Latimer never denied his guilt. After the act he drove to the local RCMP and turned himself in. The jury in the original case was also kept ignorant of the consequences of their decision to convict him of second degree murder. When, despite their recommendation for a very minimal prison sentence(one year), they were informed of the full consequences of their decision many broke down crying. The original judge's sentence of one year prison and one year "house arrest" on the Latimer farm was overturned on appeal by a vindictive prosecution. It is interesting to note that Robert Latimer is the only person to ever serve any jail time for a "mercy killing" in Canada. In other cases the prosecution has exercised its discretion by laying much more minor charges such as "administering a noxious substance" or manslaughter. In yet other cases the juries involved have been fully aware of their rights, and have opted for their right to acquit despite the evidence.
The case of Robert Latimer is what might be called in epidemiology an "index case". There was little doubt that a vast majority of the Canadian population at the time of the trial believed that he should serve a very minimal prison sentence (if any at all). About the only ones who disagreed were the professional disabled lobby (representing about 0.0001% of the population) who evoked the "slippery slope' argument 9corrupted, of course, by their own financial interests) and those who disagreed on religious terms (about 10% of the population, as most people pick and chose the decrees of their sect). The reaction to the denial of his parole has been even more vehement.
The "index case" of this reaction can perhaps be best expressed by the frequently expressed comment that "Karla Homulka got parole and has even had a baby" while Latimer rots in jail. The matter is often elaborated by the fact that really and truly evil murderers receive sentences that are far less than that that Latimer received. They are often out in two years. The public perception in this case is quite correct. Latimer is not only a "minimal risk to re-offend". He is a zero risk to re-offend. The public cannot see why, when there are numerous cases of people who went on to murder while on bail, on day-parole, on early release, on serving a tiny bit of their sentence,etc., that a harmless man should not be released. If the purpose is "denunciation" people see that there are other criminal acts in our society that are far more deserving of such "denunciation" than what Latimer did. Almost every murder in the news involves someone who has received far more mercy than Latimer has received.
Here is where Molly has got to intervene with her final "in". Never mind that she has medical knowledge that allows her to judge just how serious the situation that the Latimers were in. Never mind that she has personal knowledge from both her family and from meeting other people in similar situations who were not in the extreme situation of the Latimers, something that those who cry for Latimer's head rarely have, approaching it as they do from religious abstractions. I can only hope that a curse that such people who put abstractions over people comes true, and they suffer at last 1/10th as much as the Latimers suffered. The final clincher is that Molly has direct experience of having a family member murdered. Almost two decades ago her favourite nephew was killed in a manner sufficient that we had to have the classical "closed-coffin funeral". The whole thing became quite the media sensation as it dovetailed into politically correct angst about "gay-bashing", even though the evil thug's own "sexuality" was more than slightly questionable. It is rather off-putting to see your kin's name mentioned on page 2 of the Globe and Mail in reference to the hunt for the killer. Yeah, it became a NATIONAL CASE. To make a long story short the killer was apprehended, tried, convicted and imprisoned. Of course for a far shorter time than Mr. Latimer is destined to serve. The last that Molly heard of this reptile was an interview with him on the CBC where he was crying the blues about the lack of medical care for Hep-C and Aids infected people in prison. After he got his early release, of course. All that I can wish for him the most slow, unpleasant and painful death possible. May his disease eat him up and rot him from the inside, and if I should be so privileged I would wish to be present at his death-bed to mock him. It would be a great existential privilege.
OK, you get the idea about why I often get quite aggressive with juvenile "anarchists" (sic) who want to glorify criminality, often to the point of not just foolishly trying to recruit thugs-a goddamn bad idea- to the ideology but even to elevating such people as 'examples" of the class struggle. All that I can say to this is that, if you want to propose an "alternative" to the present society, that you shouldn't make it so obvious that your alternative is worse than what presently exists. But there is a matter in the present Latimer case that goes far beyond the tiny anarchist movement and how some within it are bloodily determined to preserve their illusions of superiority by being as illusionarily radical as possible.
This other matter revolves around the so-called "justification" that the Parole Board gave for their decision. Mr. Latimer expressed "no remorse" for his actions. That is not exactly true. He was an ordinary Saskatchewan farmer, unaccustomed to either lying nor covering up his motivations by psycho-babble. He was questioned about his "feelings" at the time when he killed his daughter, and, like a normal person who does not make their living by manipulation, he responded by speaking the truth about Tracy's condition. In the worldview of the mind-worms, however, truth is irrelevant, and they responded by saying that he "lacked insight and understanding regarding what he did". They sentenced him to more prison time and , what may be worse, "counselling". In other times and places what they sentenced him to was "further political re-education". The grossest part of their lie was when a spokesman for the board went on the CBC radio and tried to deny that Latimer's "lack of remorse" had anything to do with the decision of the Board by invoking a piece of bureaucratic newspeak by invoking the quote above. Gross obvious fucking lies. Those who wish to replace the previous roles of the priests in our society DEMAND that ritual acts of contrition be laid before their altars, no matter how contradictory to common sense such rituals are.
Molly has spoken about this before on this blog. Mr Latimer has has, according to this holy incantation "issues". Bullshit and double bullshit. The board may not even disagree with Latimer's act, as the great majority of Canadians do not. What offended them was his refusal to speak the language of their class and its pretensions to religious power. This is why Karla Homulka got parole. She actually "studied" the arcane pseudo-science of "psychology" in prison and was evil enough and shameless enough to parrot back the bullshit to her parole board. Most of us in the real world recognize what a liar she is, but the whole idea of "lies" is beyond the intellectual (sic) horizon of good social workers- especially when they lie constantly. What Mr. Latimer is is a "political prisoner" with far more justification for such a term than almost any of the criminals that my dear deluded comrades want to raise to such a status in the USA. His act of killing his daughter who could not be relieved of her insufferable pain in any other way is far more worthy than those who rob banks and then say they did it for "political reasons". His defiance of the high priests of the Parole Board is also a much more direct attack on at least one of the organizations that oppress ordinary people than the lying justifications of those who commit crimes for their own benefit. It is a clear "class matter", and, if it cannot be seen as such, it is merely evidence of how far the "left" has strayed from its traditional populist basis.