Sunday, July 06, 2008



ANARCHIST MOVEMENT-ZIMBABWE:

ZIMBABWEAN ANARCHISTS ON THE CRISIS IN THEIR COUNTRY:

The following interviews with two anarchists from the country of Zimbabwe has been republished from the platformist Anarckismo site. The original source is the South African platformist Zabalaza Anarchist Communist Front site. Once more anarchism is spreading worldwide. The following gives an unique anarchist perspective on the recent events in Zimbabwe.

.............................

ZACF interviews two libertarian activists from Zimbabwe
by Zabalaza Anarchist Communist Front
A member of the ZACF poses the same set of questions to two activists from Zimbabwe.
The first interviewee, Biko Mutsaurwa, is an anarcho-communist from the Uhuru Network and facilitator for the Toyi Toyi Artz Kollektive in Harare. The second interviewee is Comrade Fatso, AKA Samm Farai Monro, a cultural activist and artistic facilitator for Magamba! The Cultural Activist Network.

The interviews were conducted in Johannesburg on 21st of June, 2008 - the day before MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai announced his decision to not participate in the June 27 presidential election run-off.

Interview with Biko Mutsaurwa, anarcho-communist from the Uhuru Network and facilitator for the Toyi Toyi Artz Kollektive.
Conducted in Johannesburg on 21st June 2008 by the ZACF.
ZACF: Have you heard about the regime's alleged 3-stage election scheme ("electoral cleansing", falsify the vote, declare a state of emergency)?

Biko: About the regimes intentions to outrightly rig the Zimbabwe electoral outcome I could say that i am convinced merely from watching the regimes reactions to the 29th March elections results that Mugabe has refused to accept that he was defeated in that election. The state media has continued to propagate the myths that there was no election winner. So I’m clear that their intention was to rig the election. With regards to how the regime is actually intent on cleansing after the elections, decimating the middle lay of activists within the Movement for Democratic Change I could say that I have second hand information, actually I got it from my mother who was forced-marched to a ZANU PF rally this Wednesday, 18th June 2008 where war veterans from the Zimbabwe Liberation War Veterans Association addressed that rally and they came to say that they were not there to campaign but they were there to inform the people that ZANU PF was not going to accept the electoral victory of MDC and also that they were going to come back to beat up the residents of Chitungwiza, where I stay with my family, primarily because Chitungwiza has been traditionally voting for the MDC.
ZACF: Can you tell us something about conditions on the ground in Zimbabwe, the extent of repression etc.. We'd like to hear about something else other than the repeated arrests of Tsvangirai & other MDC big-shots.
Biko: The arrests of senior MDC leaders comes in the wake of ZANU PF’s realisation that this time around the MDC leadership is prepared to call upon the masses of Zimbabwe to rise up and defend their vote using peoples power.The specific incident that gave rise to this awakening in terms of ZANU PF’s realisation was Tendai Biti’s announcement of the parallel voter tabulation result on 30th March. The arrests are merely a signal that ZANU PF is going to incapacitate the higher MDC leadership and later decimate the middle-layer MDC leadership that is community organisers so that there is no organised resistance in the wake of ZANU PF’s rigging of elections but also, which is much widespread, there have been very serious instances of ZANU PF militia in the rural areas mutilating the bodies of murdered MDC activists. A case in point is a very close friend of mine, Comrade Tonderai Ndira, who was a community organiser but also - in the wake of what is happening - was agitating for the armed self-defence of the oppressed communities particularly in the rural areas. He was murdered in one of the rural areas by the Central Intelligence Organisation in the remote rural district. His brother could only recognise him by a wrist band that he wore. That is the extent to which ZANU PF is prepared to deal with ordinary people. There are so many numerous names of people that have been murdered by ZANU PF.
ZACF: And the economy: hyperinflation, availability of food & other basic necessities, unemployment are common knowledge. Perhaps you have some comments on the origin of the economic crisis?
Biko: The ZANU PF regime came into power masquerading as a socialist party. It had as part of its ideological tradition the Stalinist conception of revolution. By 1991 even workers rose up against the ZANU PF dictatorship but by then it had consolidated its power and by 1990 ZANU PF had ceased to event act as a pseudo-leftist party and it outrightly embraced the right wing policies of the Bretton Woods institutions, the IMF and the World Bank, by adopting the economic Structural Adjustment Programmes.The revolution that is currently underway in Zimbabwe is a revolution that has been sparked by the peoples reaction to the adverse effects brought about by the economic Structural Adjustment Programmes of the 1990s. By 1999 we see the formation of the MDC, and the rest is history.
ZACF: What is the role of the MDC? Have they handled things well or badly? Again, historical comments on how they've blundered in the past might be helpful.
Biko: The MDC emerged in 1999 from the initiatives of the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions as a workers party, but by the year 2001 it had been hijacked by middle class intellectuals and capitalists and therefore became a cocktail of ideologies. There have been a big number of mistakes that have been committed by the MDC. The MDC has not aligned itself towards the working people in terms of its economic policies. The MDC continues to look outwards towards foreign direct investment from imperialists nations and multi-national corporations as the way forward for rebuilding the decimated Zimbabwean economy. But in terms of strategy and tactics I believe that this time the MDC has learnt from its mistakes of not agitating for peoples power, but what remains a very serious weakness at this particular point is the inability to prepare the masses for an uprising. Yes its good enough to have the leadership calling for people to get into the streets, but its not good enough because you need to have the people prepared through training, through regular actions with regards to bread and butter struggles that people are going through, because only through action can people attain confidence in using action as means to liberate themselves, which is the only way for Zimbabwe.
ZACF: Can you tell us a little about the current state of resistance & prospects for the future; whether resistance is organised primarily or only by MDC or whether there’s other resistance; the trade unions movement, civics etc.?
Biko: The Zimbabwean pro-democracy movement has been infected by a disease that we call the ‘commodification of resistance syndrome’. There are a lot of NGOs getting a lot of money from imperialist nations but they are not organising concretely where the masses of the working people are. The Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions remains a militant organisation but it has been weakened by the high rate of unemployment. Our belief as the Uhuru Network is that the key focal point is organising in communities where the majority of working people are, and here we see the very significant role of the combined Harare residents associations, but we feel that the hierarchical structure of most of these organisations organising in the communities is an impediment to the workers and poor people organising themselves in a manner that actually embodies the new forms of organisation that we envision for a new Zimbabwe.
ZACF: Have you read an article by Dale McKinley of the APF on the strategy of resistance for Zimbabwe? And what were your thoughts?
Biko: I have read articles that comrade Dale wrote in response to a discussion that had been initiated by comrade Oupa Lehulere of Khanya College with regards to the centrality of the industrial working class proletariat contrasted to the role of the social movements organising in communities. I think by and large he does to an certain extent balance the role of social movements in communities with the industrial working class. What I’m not clear about is what kind of organisational structure comrade Dale argues for, because one of the major impediments that I myself have experienced in terms of organising is that workers are usually disempowered by the vanguardist politics of the revolutionary parties and the hierarchies in terms of central command, for example when organising strikes. So I can’t really say that I understand what comrade Dale would argue for in terms of structure, but that would be a key concern for me.
ZACF: Please tell us a bit about the regime's methods of repression. How far does it depend on firearms etc; how important is the Chinese connection in terms of arms trade etc.? Can you confirm whether or not the infamous arms shipment got through to Zimbabwe?
Biko: The shipment was actually confirmed to have been received by a minister in the regimes cabinet, so the shipment is in Zimbabwe now. It is also another thing though that the fascist regime is prepared to use all means of violence, firearms are central to that to suppress any resistance. So firearms are key. ZANU PF years ago trained youth militia under the National Youth Service Training Programme and those militia are currently on standby and will be unleashed after the elections for the cleansing of activists. Currently what they are using are the youth structures of their party which are by and large very active in all the various wards of the country. The police and the army were the first to perpetrate repression and violence and this we saw in the pre-29th March period and also of significance is the large number of activists who have been murdered, middle layer leaders within the MDC, who were actually murdered by members of the army during Operation Command which is in charge of running the country. The army the police and the CIO.
ZACF: What about the repressive forces receiving training in Korea?
Biko: It is very key because I’m in fact aware of a number of places, particularly in Harare’s Milton suburb that are being used as training centers by not only Korean but also Chinese military personnel to train ZANU PF cadres in methods of torture. This I can confirm because I’ve witnessed it with my own eyes.
ZACF: How long is it actually going to take to get rid of Mugabe, and what happens then? A government of national unity or the MDC? What kind of policies will such a government adopt? Is there a danger of a return to neo-liberalism; and what can be done to resist this?
Biko: Frankly I am not a firm believer in parliamentary politics as a tool for the liberation of the working and poor people, so I’m pretty much indifferent to what is going to happen after Mugabe because what is clear to me is that the working and poor people in Zimbabwe are not ready to take control of their lives because they have been brainwashed by the ideology of the ruling class. The MDC, if assumes in power - which I would say will happen in the next year or so if peoples power and the resistance is organised properly - will pursue neo-liberal polices. The only positive thing that I can see about an MDC government is slightly broadened democratic space within which I think revolutionary organisations, activists and movements can operate much more flexibly to fight neo-liberalism.
ZACF: What about the role of other regional and international powers, such as South Africa, UK, US, and China? Economic interests, inter-imperialist rivalries, links to government & opposition etc.
Biko: Central to efforts by the international community to resolve the Zimbabwean crisis has been South Africa, particularly Thabo Mbeki’s role as the mediator of the Sadc initiated dialog. Thabo Mbeki I think is by and large motivated by the South African state’s sub-imperialist interest in the economy of Zimbabwe. I think also key to understanding his relationship to ZANU PF is the relationship between the ANC, as a party, to ZANU PF. We must also understand that Comrade Mbeki, if I might call him a comrade (laughs), was educated - or his education was financed - by ZANU PF; he was staying in Harare at the hospitality of Robert Mugabe, and when he goes to meet Robert Mugabe he meets him as his superior in terms of the nationalists as a movement. The role of the West and the UK is motivated by the failure of the ZANU PF regime to resolve the land issue in Zimbabwe and also the question of ownership of means of production, which is central to the struggle. The United Kingdom, as a state, harbors a hope that they might be able to reverse the loss of the estates and perhaps companies or economic interests in Zimbabwe as a result of Mugabe’s pseudo-leftist parties if an MDC government comes to power. The US is an imperialist nation whose motives around “resolving” international problems is purely economic. They would want to open up the economy of Zimbabwe to the multinational corporations that come from that particular state. So they do not have the interests of the Zimbabwean people at heart. In terms of the international community helping with the resolution of the crisis it can only be people to people solidarity; poor and working people, revolutionaries and organisations - similar minded - in various countries all over the world rendering solidarity to the Zimbabwe people with the interests of the empowerment of poor and working people in Zimbabwe.
ZACF: What can you say about Thabo Mbeki, and do you think that Jacob Zuma will be any better when he comes to power?
Biko: The relationship with the Zimbabwean state if ZANU PF is in power will clearly be acrimonious because Jacob Zuma appears to be the new favourite puppet of the West in light of his ability to hoodwink the trade unions - Cosatu as a movement - into supporting him. It has become clear I think to most of the imperialists that Jacob Zuma has the popular support of the people but he is clearly another puppet in terms of his relations with companies, the capitalists, and arms dealers and he won’t have anything to offer the people of Zimbabwe, the ordinary masses; but he will be, after Mbeki, the imperialists next favourite puppet in terms of how their strategies are implemented within the Southern African region.
ZACF: In terms of international solidarity, what can we do? Who is helping in SA and elsewhere?
Biko: The transportation workers union I think signaled the direction that workers need to take, unlike what we have seen - even though Cosatu has been militant at times - but we have seen a lot of talk-shops around what’s going on in Zimbabwe. But I think concrete action along the lines of what SATAWU did in stopping the shipment of arms is the next direction.
ZACF: Any comments on the recent so-called xenophobic pogroms in South Africa? Anything about Zimbabweans who fled the pogroms back across the Limpopo? How significant is this from a Zimbabwean point of view and what does it say about the South African government and people?
Biko: Firstly I’d like to register my understanding of the fundamental causes of the xenophobic attacks which I think are primarily rooted in the rate of unemployment currently obtained in South Africa, which is a direct result of the capitalist economic structure that the South African state is pursuing, and also the artificial food shortages which are superficially created by the global capitalist complex in order to initiate a hike in prices. I think those particular causes resonate with the situation obtaining in Zimbabwe and do point to us having a common enemy, which is capitalism. It is particularly disappointing though that the xenophobic attacks also point towards and indicate to us the lack of understanding of each others struggles that we as working people face, which we have to overcome in order to be able to overcome the system. The impact of people fleeing the xenophobic attacks and coming back to Zimbabwe has on one hand the effect of bolstering the vote of the MDC, because clearly those people are people who are disaffected by the ZANU PF regime. But it has also tragically had the effect of worsening their plight because the violence that did obtain in that short period in South Africa is incomparable to the violence being perpetrated by the ZANU PF regime back home, and these people are primary targets because most of them did flee after some resistance activities and it is like throwing these activists back into the lion’s den, and this is the tragedy of our situation.
ZACF: There are rumors that MDC agents could actually have acted as provocateurs and brought about these attacks in order to cause Zimbabweans to flee back home and therefore bolster their support during the elections. Do you think this is a possibility, or do you think its the South African government trying to divert responsibility?
Biko: Whilst I cannot really comment with confidence about what really happened in South Africa as I was in Zimbabwe I am inclined to believe that third force conspiracies are really something to drive us away from the responsibility that the ANC government has towards the poor and working people in South Africa which is the fundamental cause. Like I said before the MDC is actually a cocktail of ideologies and is a party that cuts across class; most of the influential people in the MDC are not really pro-working people so it is actually possible that people whose interests do not lie with the working people might be able to have their buddies to influence this but I would much rather focus on the role that the polices pursued by the ANC government have had on the xenophobic attacks.
ZACF: What role do you think nationalism might have played in these attacks?
Biko: Capital is globalised, the capitalist in Jo’burg is able to send huge amounts of money to Harare in seconds whereas the peoples’ movement is restricted by these borders, and that people are forced to recognise these ideological constructs limited to the ruling classes propaganda with these geographical zones and I think that has been key to shaping the thoughts that we have seen manifest in this very tragic way during the xenophobic attacks. And I think that our role as progressives and revolutionaries is then to try to share the ideas that we uphold of a world that has no borders, and I think that is the way forward in addressing xenophobia across the world.
ZACF: Any messages to the international anarchist movement? Any appeals or suggestions for how the international anarchist movement can support the struggle in Zimbabwe and help the advancement of anarchist ideas there?
Biko: Firstly, ahoy comrades and we appreciate the efforts that the movement has been receiving so far. We as the Uhuru Network have significantly benefited from our relationship with the ZACF in terms of the literature that we have managed to get and also the experiences that we share with comrades. Currently the realisation that we need to remind each other that the anarchist movement is a very small movement within the broader leftist movement but also within the pro-democracy movement and that our true anarchist comrades are at risk, especially when we have levels or repression such as are obtaining in Zimbabwe. We need to constantly communicate, interact, share experiences and also information about actions happening because when shit hits the fan it is only an anarchist that will be able to give appropriate solidarity to a fellow anarchist comrade.

Interview with Comrade Fatso AKA Samm Farai Monro, cultural activist and artistic facilitator for Magamba! The Cultural Activist Network, Zimbabwe.
Conducted in Johannesburg on 21st June 2008 by the ZACF.
ZACF: Have you heard about the regime's alleged 3-stage election scheme ("electoral cleansing", falsify the vote, declare a state of emergency)?
Fatso: I heard of this plan, I think I read about it in the media and its obvious that they’re going ahead with the first two. At least there definitely is electoral cleansing going on, in the sense of getting rid of opposition support from the rural areas, where the majority of voters are, and also getting rid of any local election observers and poll monitors. And on declaring a state of emergency; its quite likely that’s something they could do in the build up to or straight after the elections. All they’d need is a peaceful demonstration or even less they could once against fabricate stories of supposed conspiracies, and I wouldn’t put that beyond them.
ZACF: Do you think this is an accurate understanding of Mugabe's intentions and, if so, will he pull it off?
Fatso: I think what is likely is they will rig the elections. They’ve shown they don’t give a damn about even the foreign observers; there have been two people shot in front of Namibian election observers a couple of days ago. If they don’t declare a state of emergency a very likely scenario is that, after winning, they’ll patch together a government of national unity which would be more in the sense of absorbing the MDC and then slowly taking it apart as it becomes part of the government, which of course ZANU PF would run.
ZACF: Can you tell us something about conditions on the ground in Zimbabwe, the extent of repression etc.. We'd like to hear about something else other than the repeated arrests of Tsvangirai & other MDC big-shots.
Fatso: What’s going on on the ground is the abduction, torture and murder of grassroots activists from across the board. Mainly MDC activists are being targeted but also those from Women of Zimbabwe Arise, from the National Constitutional Assembly, different movements have also been targeted. Four bodies of MDC activists were found a few days ago. They were from Chitungwiza, which is the biggest township in Harare, and they had been abducted, tortured, beaten and murdered. And there are also political prisoners. WOZA’s leadership has been arrested and is being held until after the elections. What ZANU has now started is that dictatorial trend of taking political prisoners, which it didn’t necessarily do in the past. Those are some of the things that are happening.
ZACF: And the economy: hyperinflation, availability of food & other basic necessities, unemployment are common knowledge. Perhaps you have some comments on the origin of the economic crisis?
Fatso: Everyone knows about the hyper inflation and that we’re moving into the trillions. You have to spend trillions of dollars on certain basic things. Economically there has been a decline, really since the 1990s, with the introduction of Structural Adjustment Programmes and the commercialisation of parastatals, the removal of tariffs on Western imported goods and the removal of subsides that supported local industry. All of this was World Bank backed Structural Adjustment Programmes which led to the average worker being twice as poor in 1995 as they were in 1980, it led to a large amount of school drop-outs, it led to increased unemployment and worse wages. So the economic decline really started more in the 1990s, and that’s something that doesn’t get reported on that much in foreign media. And of course then this precipitated Mugabe fighting against those demanding economic justice; the workers and students. Mugabe fighting against them by using the land issue, and beginning to repress his opposition and destroying the economy in order to entrench their patronage system; so there’s been a steady decline since the mid-nineties until now.
ZACF: What is the role of the MDC? Have they handled things well or badly? Again, historical comments on how they've blundered in the past might be helpful.
Fatso: I give respect to MDC for having fought the struggle and for having risked so much. I do think that strategically they’ve made mistakes, and their relationship with the people hasn’t always been as direct as it should have been and their information hasn’t gotten out as much as it should have. I do respect them still for putting themselves in the forefront of the struggle, but I think also that there has to be a lot more coordination with the civics and social movements.
ZACF: Some people have criticised Tsvangirai for having spent so long outside of Zimbabwe, trying to muster International support instead of providing leadership on the ground. Any comments?
Fatso: I think it was, on the one hand, a wise idea for him to leave the country and drum up support in the region. I think he achieved a lot within Sadc. Definitely he achieved quite a few breakthroughs with Sadc heads of state in getting them to support the peoples’ side of what’s going on in Zimbabwe, but I do think he stayed out for too long and peoples’ hopes started dissipating. And he is now back - I think he came back a bit late - but he is now back and he obviously always has risks of arrest and assassination on his head. You’ve seen what they’ve done to Tendai Biti the Secretary General, who is one of the key players and one of the brightest minds in the MDC. By taking Tendai out of the game they have definitely dealt quite a harsh blow to MDC.
ZACF: Can you tell us a little about the current state of resistance & prospects for the future; whether resistance is organised primarily or only by MDC or whether there’s other resistance; the trade unions movement, civics etc.?
Fatso: I think there’s various types of resistance, MDC’s is one form. Amongst the civics I think the most powerful movement is Women of Zimbabwe Arise, a very powerful social movement made up of women, which focuses on social justice issues, takes to the streets where necessary, believes in direct action and is a national movement that has got sections all over the country. And then there are other forms of resistance. There are the civics, and there’s those like ourselves that use arts and culture in the struggle. We’ve got our network Magamba! The Cultural Activist Network, and we put on different resistance shows as ways of keeping peoples inspiration high, giving people that food for resistance. I think there are different forms of resistance that happen and no, its not at all exclusively the MDC.
ZACF: At the Southern African Social Forum in 2005 you had a performance in Harare Gardens that was openly critical of the regime, in broad view of everyone, yet there wasn’t any state repression metered out against people that participated. Is that because of the high profile of cultural activists, or what do you attribute that to?
Fatso: It’s a difficult one. They do come and threaten and monitor; they monitor our performances, they call us up afterwards to interrogate us informally. Sometimes they probably think their presence is enough to stop people coming, and sometimes their presence does stop some people coming into our shows. We’ve had that before, where people said “No I’m not coming in because I know those guys, I know what they’re capable of”. But their strategy is also to censor the arts, I mean my album has been banned. They’ve given a blanket silence in all state media meanwhile the non-state media has given it very good reviews -of course, its a resistance album - but they censor those who don’t support them.
ZACF: Please tell us a bit about the regime's methods of repression. How far does it depend on firearms etc; how important is the Chinese connection in terms of arms trade etc.?
Fatso: The regime will always resort to using arms and especially right now, in the build up to elections, there are more reports of people being shot. The soldiers and Youth Militia are all being used in an attempt to destroy the peoples will. With regards to the Chinese, there has been an important connection there; they have provided everything from police vehicles, baton sticks, army vehicles, arms and the like. So there is a definite connection.
ZACF: Can you confirm whether or not the infamous arms shipment got through to Zimbabwe?
Fatso: I’ve got no specific information of on that.
ZACF: How long is it actually going to take to get rid of Mugabe, and what happens then? A government of national unity or the MDC? What kind of policies will such a government adopt? Is there a danger of a return to neo-liberalism; and what can be done to resist this?
Fatso: One never knows how long it will take to get rid of Mugabe, but I do think its the final days of ZANU PF. I don’t think they can go on much longer. I think a form of government of national unity is what would come about, even MDC have talked of this; that there is such polarisation in Zimbabwe that the MDC alone may not be able to take all the people with it. So there is likelihood that if the MDC was to form a government of them bringing in certain elements of ZANU PF, more reformed so-called progressive elements. There are progressive aspects to what MDC wants to put in place; they talk a lot about a people-based economy and people-centered constitution, but it needs to be seen in practice because one problem with Zimbabwe is that there’s a big likelihood that, in a new, independent and free Zimbabwe, that in order to get foreign investment a lot of the country and its resources will be sold off to foreign investors and foreign corporations. That would be a very quick-fix way of bringing money into the economy, but of course we’d end up seeing resources being in the hand of foreigners and Zimbabweans not benefiting. So I think that’s one think to look out for, and another is getting into debt. We have a huge illegitimate foreign debt that we should not pay. Some of it was incurred by Rhodesia and the rest was incurred by ZANU PF and none of that should be paid back; its illegitimate. The policies that should be put in place should be policies that focus more on social and economic justice, and I think that if those kind of policies don’t start to be put in place then people, because the democratic space would technically be larger under the MDC one would hope, people will still have that knowledge and tradition of the basic struggles for water, the basic struggles for food that formed a lot of the core struggles during our struggle for democracy today and would hopefully be able to continue the struggle for social and economic justice. I don’t think it ends with MDC being in power, I think freedom is never fully attained and a lot of the movements will morph into new movements and new movement will be born and the struggle for peoples basic socio-economic rights will continue.
ZACF: What about the role of other regional and international powers, such as South Africa, the UK, US, and China? Economic interests, inter-imperialist rivalries, links to government & opposition?
Fatso: I think a new Zimbabwe will be a prime picking ground for South Africa, the UK, US and also I think its very important for any government in place to be aware of what progressive policies have to be in place and not selling off the country and its assets, because Zimbabwe had the second biggest industrial base in the region with self-sufficiency in food, and that’s something which has to be reestablished without selling it out to the foreigners.
ZACF: What can you say about Thabo Mbeki, and do you think that Jacob Zuma will be any better when he comes to power?
Fatso: I think Mbeki has been an absolute dismal failure in being the Sadc appointed mediator. Zuma’s statements have been progressive, but then he’s also someone who is known to be a populist and known to ride on popular waves of popular thinking. So his statements and the new ANC leadership’s statements on Zimbabwe have been much more progressive than anything we’ve heard from Mbeki and his ANC, but the proof of it will be in the action rather than in the public statements.
ZACF: In terms of international solidarity, what can we do? Who is helping in SA and elsewhere?
Fatso: I think a lot of Zimbabwean people were very empowered by the regional solidarity that came about from the civics especially in South Africa around the arms issue, Cosatu affiliated trade unions refusing to offload, refusing to transport the shipment. The South African Litigations Center taking the boat to court. I think that was very powerful civic solidarity; the South African government had nothing to do with it. That was showing how social movements and civics can be a powerful force for good within society. So I think actions like that where social movements take the forefront, don’t wait for governmental action, I think that’s important. Many forms of solidarity can happen; even in the concert today when people walk in they will sign individual letters addressed to Thabo Mbeki on Zimbabwe, and those will be sent to him. So different forms of awareness raising, different forms of solidarity are key in struggle.
ZACF: Any comments on the recent so-called xenophobic pogroms in South Africa? Anything about Zimbabweans who fled the pogroms back across the Limpopo? How significant is this from a Zimbabwean point of view and what does it say about the South African government and people?
Fatso: I think what its shown is what happens after more than ten years of elitist policies within South Africa that have lead to a blossoming so-called black diamond middle class and a hugely growing economy but a population where 40% are unemployed and most of the people live in absolutely squalid conditions. That should be a wake-up call. The neo-liberal policies that have been in place have not worked, they’ve benefitted the rich and not the poor and that should be a wake-up call to the ANC about what policies its putting in place. And at the same time, from our side, a better Zimbabwe means a better South Africa in the sense that we won’t have all these refugees coming over to South Africa if we didn’t have the crisis in Zimbabwe in the first place.
Comrade Fatso

CANADIAN ANARCHIST MOVEMENT-HALIFAX:
EVENTS AT THE HALIFAX FREE SCHOOL:
Molly has mentioned these people before. The Halifax Free Skool is a Halifax City collective dedicated to self education in a libertarian atmosphere. in addition to their regular activities (such a meeting tonight) they hope to stimulate other projects. This Wednesday, July 9th there will be a meeting at the North Memorial Library in hope of setting up a new artist co-op. Drop on by if you live in the Halifax area. They also say that they will be bringing out a new workshop schedule by the 12th.

ANARCHIST MOVEMENT-JAPAN:
RESISTANCE AGAINST THE G8 MEETING IN JAPAN:
The following item from the A-Infos website may be partially "dated", but it should be noted that the protests against the G8 summit in Hokkaido are still continuing.
..................................
Resistance Against G8 Summit, Arrests and Detentions of Activists and Independent Journalists in Japan
Japan July 7th-9th - In the lead up to the G8 Summit in Japan from July 7th through 9th, Japanese authorities have arrested domestic activists and have detained numerous foreign independent media journalists and anti-G8 protesters. At least six independent journalists and ten academics have been detained by Japanese immigration officials in the past weeks, including Andrej Grubacic, professor of sociology at the University of San Francisco.
Police arrested eight protesters on June 29, as 1,500 people marched against the G8 Summit in Tokyo's fashionable fashionable Shibuya and Shinjuku districts. Earlier this month, workers in Kamagasaki clashed with police and security in the face of violent repression and brutality against at least one worker.
Japan's security budget for the G8 Summit is at least 30 billion yen ($283 million), topping the 113 million euros ($186 million) Germany spent to host the summit of the world's most powerful "democratic" nations.
The G8 Summit will be held in the resort town of Toyako on the northern island of Hokkaido. Japanese activists opposing the summit call it an "arbitrary meeting of governments dominating the global financial market with the World Trade Organization and Free Trade Agreements". They object to the fact that developing nations are forced to accept agreements like NAFTA in exchange for ODA (Official Developmental Assistance).
At the local level, they are concerned that in recent years Japanese social welfare has been reduced and the working poor have suffered. Agribusiness, a favorite topic of G8 discussion, runs counter to Japanese tradition of respect for individual farmers. At the same time, the US is urging Japan to re-arm despite having a constitution imposed by US Occupation Forces that calls for Japan to forever remain a peaceful nation.
The US led wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are also targets of the G8 protests, and caricatures of President Bush with the theme "Wanted for Murder" were seen in internet video of the demonstrations.
On June 30th, the Counter-G8 International Forum opened in Hokkaido and will conclude on July 1st. Media G8way reports that anti-G8 activists from Japan and across the world came together to strategize on how to resist the G8 and construct alternatives to a system in which "financial crises, food crises and ecological destruction are inherent.
"Meanwhile, organizers continue to prepare protests and demonstrations against the summit. Daily six hour marches are planned from one of the main camps, Toyoura camp, into town, and a major demonstration estimated at 10,000 people is scheduled for July 5 in Sapporo.

PEOPLE:
MORE ON LUCIEN LARRE:


The name of Lucien Larre was briefly mentioned in a previous post on this blog in connection with the awarding of the Governor General's Order of Canada Medal to Henry Morgentaler. As previously said Larre is a Vancouver priest who has returned his own Order of Canada medal in protest at the acceptance of Morgentaler into the Order. As previously mentioned Larre has two previous convictions for common assault in connection with his previous work at Bosco Home in Saskatchewan. But there's a lot more to this, and now, like the radio show says, "here's the rest of the story".



When reading about Larre's protest Molly's foggy, almost senile, mind heard a little bell in the background. "That name seems familiar". Familiar it was indeed as Larre's run-in with the law occurred back in Molly's old stomping grounds of Saskatchewan. Molly had long since left the province before Larre's run-in with justice in 1992, but she can certainly remember the name being mentioned in the Catholic environment where she grew up. She can also remember a certain satisfaction when the bugger was finally caught.


What brought all this back was reading an item in the local press where it was claimed that Larre had been acquitted of the charges. Could Molly have made a mistake ? Is the Pope really the only infallible person on Earth ? Well, no such mistake was made. Larre indeed was convicted, as the article below from yesterday's Globe and Mail makes plain. What happened is that he originally faced 11 charges, but was convicted on only 2 of them. In 1997 he applied for and obtained a pardon. The only question in Molly's mind is the date of this pardon, early or late 1997. Conservative Brian Mulroney was Prime Minister in the first half of 1997, and Jean Chrétien was Prime Minister in the latter half. While the granting of pardons is theoretically free from political interference there is a lot that depends upon political appointees.



In 1996 changes to the rules of the Order have provided for people being stripped of the award if "if they have been convicted of a criminal offence or if their conduct runs afoul of public standards or is sanctioned by a professional association". The rules are not retroactive so Larre got to keep his award despite his previous conviction. Since the new rules came into force only two people have been removed from the Order, Alan Eagleston in 1998 and David Ahenakew in 2002 (see below). What is interesting is that "professional censure" is also cause for removal. In 2006 Larre was ordered to stop his practice of "therapy" and removed from the registry by the B.C. College of Psychologists. The court docket of the case when he appealed to the Supreme Court -and lost- is available at the site of the Canada Protective Parents Association. Larre has launched yet another appeal which is due to be heard this fall.



Molly went on over to the website of the Bosco Center(sic). Yes, the centre is actually "centres" (4 of them in B.C. and Alberta). And yes, despite being a Canadian outfit they use the American spelling of "center" rather than the Canadian "centre". The type of "therapy' being offered there is quite American in nature, being one of the industrial wastes that the USA has exported to the rest of the world. Larre took something of a 'post-graduate' training at the Fielding Insitute in Santa Barbara California. This outfit is accredited, so far as such things go, in the throbbing pulsing world centre of all that is flaky known as "the Golden State"(pretend you have gold and the suckers will come). The "therapy" is heavily dependent upon the rather dubious ideas of "biofeedback", and, while certainly a step up from Larre's methods back in Saskatchewan, still reeks of quackery. For a good overview of the state of this "therapy"go to Quackwatch and google "biofeedback". Larre's deregistration in BC was due to several public complaints lodged with the College of Psychologists.
The Unrepentant Old Hippy blog has much more on this matter, and I urge you to drop over there. The Saskatchewan Knights of Columbus were determined to keep the name of the Bosco School alive after Larre's disgrace, and they presently run the Columbus Bosco School in that province. One hopes that it is less of a maximum security "joint" than its "honoured" predecessor. Molly also found out that Bosco Home ("Bosco Prison Camp" ????) was the subject of controversy long before Larre was brought to justice. In the Hansard for the Saskatchewan Legislature of 1989 the record speaks of "escapes" and "riots" by the child inmates over mistreatment. It also speaks of how this outfit was generously funded by the provincial government. But that is a matter for another blog.
What I must say now, however, is how this matter has reminded Molly of a subject she hasn't given too much thought to recently- the nature of evil. There are a great number of reasons why people commit evil acts in this world, and self-interest is the base of most of them. In that sense we are all evil. We all act now and then to further our goals even though we know the act is wrong. Often we lie to ourselves about these acts. The crude pop-psychology term of "denial" has been coined in recent decades to describe this act of self-deception, even though this term obscures more than it reveals. Yet, there are two obvious cases where such a term applies not at all. One is the psychopath who simply lacks anything remotely resembling either guilt or shame. But there is a much greater source of evil in this world. The great bone-shattering, world-changing, titanium steel strong evil is perpetrated by those who commit their acts under the delusion that they are doing good, under an ironclad belief that their acts, no matter how brutal or uncivilized are "right".
Molly's original introduction to such people as a child was by observing them in the personae of clerics in the Catholic Church, though Catholicism hardly has a monopoly on this sort of thing. In her later life she has seen this mindset at work in the small minority of the anarchist movement that adopts terrorist tactics. It runs through human history. NO great and massive evil was EVER committed by people who didn't think they were doing good. It's a extreme statement, but I'm willing to defend it. Some may find it hard to imagine that those they disagree with had such convictions about their motives, but it is nonetheless true. The petty idea of "denial" hardly applies in this case. There were and are no "psychological struggles" or doubts that such people struggle with. The evil acts follow logically and without remorse from the totalitarian glow of the ideology/religion that informs and spreads over the personality of the believer. Molly remembers typing Larre as such an "evil man" at a time in her life when she hardly has the words to describe such a state as she does now. "Doubt" is a wonderful thing. It keeps us from becoming such monsters.
But enough of my usual ramblings. Here's the article from the Globe and Mail.
...............................
Controversial priest returns medal in protest
WENDY STUECK
VANCOUVER -- When Catholic priest Lucien Larré shipped his Order of Canada back to Ottawa on Wednesday, he became the first person in the history of the award to return his medal as a gesture of protest.

"I realize that Dr. Morgentaler is a hero for a number of people, but there's some, maybe 40 per cent of Canadians, who don't agree with him and are deeply hurt that he was given the Order of Canada," Father Larré said in an interview yesterday.

Granting the Order of Canada to Dr. Morgentaler "degrades" the honour, he said.

In rejecting the honour, Father Larré - who was named to the order in 1983 for founding a home for troubled children that later collapsed amid allegations of abuse - put himself in the spotlight over his own past. It includes two criminal convictions in the 1990s, for which he served one day in jail, and a clash with the College of Psychologists of British Columbia, which, in 2006, suspended Father Larré's registration pending a disciplinary hearing.


Under current regulations, such a past might put Father Larré in line to be stripped of his Order of Canada rather than having the option of returning it. Since 1996, rules have provided for people to be dropped from the order if they have been convicted of a criminal offence or if their conduct runs afoul of public standards or is sanctioned by a professional association.
But the provisions are not retroactive, Lucie Caron of the Governor-General's office said yesterday.

The government is not aware of anyone other than Father Larré returning the honour, she said.
Father Larré, once nicknamed "the saint of Saskatchewan" for his work with troubled children in that province, yesterday spoke openly of his criminal convictions, emphasizing that he was acquitted on nine of 11 charges he faced in 1992 and later, in 1997, obtained a pardon and does not have a criminal record.

Father Larré founded the Bosco Homes in the 1970s to care for troubled children, some of whom had had run-ins with the law or had been kicked out of foster homes.

By the late 1980s, the homes had been hit by financial woes and allegations of abuse, which culminated in a trial in Regina in 1992.

Father Larré was convicted on one count of assault and of administering a noxious substance to a resident of the home. Yesterday, he said the assault charge stemmed from an incident when, losing his temper with a young woman who had become sexually involved with one of the boys at his school, Father Larré slapped her in the face. The noxious-substance charge stemmed from his attempts to teach kids about drug abuse by refusing to let them leave a room until they swallowed some pills, which were harmless vitamins, he said.

After the trial, Bosco Homes wound down and Father Larré moved to Alberta and then to B.C., where he now runs a centre that offers programs for children with learning disabilities and other problems.

In that role, he's come under scrutiny from the B.C. College of Psychologists, which suspended Father Larré's registration in 2006.

A B.C. Supreme Court ruling last year upheld Father Larré's suspension, noting a panel is of the view "that there are serious public protection concerns and an immediate risk to the public" if he continued to practise.

A disciplinary hearing is scheduled to reconvene this fall.

Only two people have been removed from the Order of Canada. Alan Eagleson was removed after being jailed for fraud in 1998 and David Ahenakew was removed in 2005 for anti-Semitic comments he made in 2002.

Saturday, July 05, 2008



THE STATE OF MEDICINE:

IS MEDICINE BECOMING CORRUPT:

The following item is taken from the BBC Science and Nature News website. Here in Canadaconcerns such as this have led to the creation of thge online medical journal Open Medicine where both health policy and clinical data are discussed in a atmosphere free of corporate and government interference. Go on over and have a kook.

.................................
Sulston argues for open medicine
By Matt McGrath BBC science correspondent


A Nobel Prize-winning scientist has hit out at what he terms the "moral corruption" of the medical industry.



Britain's Sir John Sulston says that profits are taking precedence over the needs of patients, particularly in the developing world.



He was speaking at the launch of a new research institute into science, ethics and innovation.
Sir John shared the 2002 Nobel Prize for medicine for his work on the genetics controlling cell division.



He is well known for his commitment to public medicine and his opposition to the privatisation of scientific information.



Eight years ago he led the fight to keep the data being derived from the Human Genome Project open and free to any scientist who wanted to use it.



'Fair access'
He says there is now great concern among researchers about private companies patenting genes and genetic tests. He is also concerned about the misuse of information, and what he terms "disease mongering".



He is taking these concerns over the direction that science and medicine are going in, onto a broader stage.



Sir John is to be the chairman of a new UK-based institute that will research the ethical questions raised by science and innovation.



He wants the group to try to provide ground rules and guidance on issues such as the patenting of genes, and how people in developing countries have fair access to medicines.
Sir John believes that our current systems place the needs of shareholders ahead of the needs of patients.


Treaty requirement
The Nobel Laureate told the BBC: "Some people would say it is not corrupt because it is not illegal, and that is true; but I consider that advertising a medicine that doesn't make clear any disadvantages of the medicine, or, in fact, the fact that most people don't need this particular medicine - I would cite, for example, anti-depressants which are hugely oversold, especially in America. This is the sort of thing I mean by corruption. It's not legal corruption; it's moral corruption."



According to Sir John, the world is at a crisis point in terms of getting medicines to sick people, particularly in the developing world.



He says that the world needs an international biomedical treaty to iron out issues over patents and intellectual property.



Sir John is setting up the Institute for Science, Ethics and Innovation with the bioethicist John Harris.



The institute is staging a one-day conference on Saturday called Who Owns Science?

Friday, July 04, 2008


ANARCHIST MOVEMENT-CZECH REPUBLIC:
THE STRIKE IS OVER-WHAT NEXT ? :
Molly has previously reported on the limited general strike that has recently occurred in the Czech Republic. Here is a further statement on the part of the Czech Anarchist Federation (Molly Note- the federation retains the name of the "Czechoslovakian Anarchist Federation" even though it is unclear if they have any serious support from the country of Slovakia which separated from the Czech Republic many years ago) on the strike, its aftermath, and the lessons derived. The following article from the A-Infos website has been slightly edited for English grammar and spelling.
................................
Czech Anarchist Federation: The strike is over, what next?
On the Tuesday 24th there was a strike against government reform, announced by a lot of labour unions. According to pre-estimates, almost one million people joined the strike. There was a strike in health services, in railways, transport in many cities was totally or partly stopped, in many factories and bureaus there was no work for one hour, taxi drivers in Prague blocked the airport, farmers blocked the Prague’s artery, and many more...
---- The strikers and the strike-breakers ----
Both trade unionists and unorganised working people joined the strike. Some people didn’t stop their work, however; they expressed their solidarity with the demands of the strikers at least with posting banners in their workplace. The number of people who joined the strike is considerable, no matter how the government tries to play this amount down.
However, in many places we could see the disunity of the working people. The reasons are various. It can be fear of losing job, career, or enforcement. In some cases, the drivers of the city transport even got lump-sum bonuses, if they didn’t join the strike.
We cannot neglect the fact, that after the Bolshevik regime in Czech Republic, there is not any tradition of striking and consciousness of solidarity among the working people.
In addition, mainstream medias in this country have always been directly or indirectly against the labour unions.
Considering all these facts, one million people in strike is good beyond expectations.
The anarchists also joined the strike
CZECHOSLOVAK ANARCHIST FEDERATION (CSAF) has decided to support the strike.
There was a manifesto and critical appeal for joining the strike on the website of CSAF.
The members of CSAF actively joined the strike, not only by direct involvement.
They also notified the public of the anarchist perspective on the government reforms, which are one of the asocial displays of the capitalist system. A lot of leaflets and stickers have been printed.
Some members of CSAF elected quiet support of the striking people in the several hours rejection of their work. Those who couldn’t join the strike directly, supported the protests by dealing leaflets, pasting stickers or by street art.
One of the CSAF regional groups hung out the anarchist flag and banner “General strike against the reforms!” on the bridge above the railway station.
The strike is over, what next?
The labour union leaders claimed the strike was successful. In the number people who joined the strike, it was certainly a success in the conditions we described above.
But we surely cannot talk about any “win”. The government politicians keep, as expected, their arrogance and the hour-long strike underwhelms them. They ignore public opinion on the reforms as well as on the U.S. radar base, which could be built here.
We can hope, this arrogance will raise “healthy” fury instead of resignation, which will be expressed through other strikes and protests.
Union leaders are speaking indistinctly about another resistance to the government reforms .However, will they lead the working people into another strike or will they rather discourage the people from it?
The strike on the 24th of June was successful only at that time. When will other steps follow, preferably the time-unlimited general strike, which the government will not be able to laugh at, anymore.

CANADIAN LABOUR:
MIGRANT FARM WORKERS IN CANADA:
The following came to Molly's mailbox, unsolicited, from an organization that styles itself as the 'Socialist Project'. A little "public health advisory" is in line here. The SP is a Trotsykist front dedicated to the tactics of "deep entry". Not being a Trotskyist, it is hard for me to comment on the "effectiveness" of such tactics from their point of view. What is sad to me is that the authors of this organization appear to be of the International Socialist Tendency, which was once a shining exemplar of "left Trotskyism" that would have nothing to do with such conspiratorial tactics. How the mightily clean have fallen ! I have to admit, effectiveness-wise, that it took me a little effort to sort them out from their website. THIS on the part of somebody who has been an anarchist, let alone a leftist for years before, much longer then the VAST majority of Trots in the world today have been simply alive. So I guess I have to hand them kudos for sheer sneakiness. I'm sure that they could fool a great number of younger people who lack the experience.
Not that I have any great hate-on for Trotskyists. Even before I became an anarchist way back in the Triassic I concurred with other independent socialists in finding them rather "cute" in an earnest, if somewhat ridiculous, "anemic poodle" sort of way. So dedicated, yet so ultimately futile. What I find disgusting about their latest incarnation as presented in organizations such as this is their cutsy, "non-sectarian"(the final refuge of those who believe in bullshit as speech) desire to "rebuild the left" in collaboration with hardened and unrepentant Maoists and others who they should run to get away from, let alone try and organize with. Molly will state it here plainly. The Canadian 'New Left' degenerated, like its American counterpart but nowhere near as seriously, for good and sufficient reasons. This corpse is long past the time when it should have a decent burial, let alone trying to resurrect it by some bizarre Marxist necromancy. The new "ultra-left" is anarchist. The other, more reformist, left has gone far beyond Marxist dogma. It's a new world. Personally I want to see anarchism take its conquest of the "ultra-left" position towards formulating a challenge to left social democracy ie the gradualism that I often advocate here. Ideas about salvaging the decaying corpse of leftism circa the 1970s are totally irrelevant to me.
All that nastiness aside, the Trots are one of the few more or less rational remnants of the "left that was", and their position on certain issues are indistinguishable from that advocated by anarchists who recognize the importance of the class struggle. It's in light of this that I reproduce the following that appeared in my mailbox. The situation of migrant agricultural workers in Canada is indeed important, and, whatever I think of the messenger, the message deserves to be delivered.
.................................
Harvest of Injustice: The Oppression of Migrant Workers on Canadian Farms
Adriana Paz
Some say that nothing happens by chance. At the very least, it was a fortunate accident that my first job, when I arrived in Canada from Bolivia three years ago, was in a tomato greenhouse in South Delta, British Columbia -- one of the first in the province to request migrant farm workers from Mexico under the federal Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program (SAWP). My job was to run from the office managers' office to the greenhouse and back relaying information on workers' productivity levels.

My first observation was that brown bodies are the pickers and white bodies are the managers. I naively asked my boss why there are no Canadians picking tomatoes. He answered me simply, "Because this is not a job for them."

That was my first lesson in Canadian social history. In B.C., most farm workers are and have long been immigrants of colour, including recently a growing number of seasonal migrants under SAWP and a related federal scheme, the Temporary Foreign Workers Program. Battered by the whims of global capital and local government policy, farm workers are the most vulnerable part of the work force, facing extreme job and economic insecurity.

According to the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives B.C., most farm workers in the province are immigrants from India, chiefly women in their 50s and 60s who came to Canada under the family reunification program. Lack of language skills and the obligation to their families to repay money advanced for their immigration and settlement pressure them to accept working conditions that Canadian workers find unacceptable.

Their plight is worsened by the Farm Labour Contractor (FLC) system, unique to the agricultural sector. The FLCs act as coyotes or intermediaries between farm workers and greenhouses/farms, determining how workers will get to the job, how long they will work, what they will earn, and so on. Obviously the FLCs do nothing to ensure respect for employment standards and safety regulations, leading to all sort of violations while the provincial authorities close their eyes.

For generations, South Asians have toiled in the fields of British Columbia under unsafe and exploitative conditions, enduring low wages and long hours of hard work while creating massive profits for agrobusiness.

Although fully informed about the corrupt FLCs and their blatant violations of employment and safety regulations, the provincial government decided in 2001/2002 to reduce enforcement. Then in 2003/2004 they excluded farm workers from various provisions of the Employment Standards Act, leaving this group of racialized labour even more vulnerable to hyperexploitation.
How to create a labour shortage.

Since 2000, farm operators in B.C. have been complaining of a shortage of labour to harvest their crops. Little science is needed to find the cause. When wages are low, often less than the legal minimum, and working conditions are substandard, workers are unwilling to work in agriculture if they have a choice.

The farm operators are of course passing on downwards the immense pressures they face from the forces of globalization and the power of agribusiness monopolies. Far from providing protection against these profiteers, the government, urged on by the farm/greenhouse operators, has adopted policies that have worsened the "labour shortage."

Nothing was done to raise farm labour wages or to increase the supply of immigrant labour. On the contrary, their measures serve to make agricultural labour not only unattractive but unlivable. To make matters worse, Citizenship and Immigration Canada in 2003 restricted the family reunification program, reducing the traditional South Asian labour source of those utilizing this program to immigrate to Canada.

Meanwhile the federal government is closing the door to permanent immigration of farm workers while steadily moving towards a U.S-style policy based on temporary migration.
All this is of course the total opposite of the "free market" policies that the government claims to support. In a free market, when demand for something goes up, so should its price. If there's a labour shortage in Canadian agriculture, wages should tend upwards until the supply of labour increases. By aggressively expanding Temporary Worker Programs, the government is manipulating market conditions to keep wages and working conditions low in order to increase corporate profits.
Continue reading:


CANADIAN LABOUR:

FOURTEEN MONTH LOCKOUT SETTLED AT LE JOURNAL DE QUÉBEC:

As promised in the last post there are a few matters arising from recent events in Québec City that I'd like to expand on. The first is the present situation of my source Media Matin Québec . This link is the website and online version of a free newspaper that has been distributed since April 22, 2007 by the locked out workers of Le Journal de Québec five days a week. This dispute pitted the workers represented by the Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE) against the Sun Media Corporation and its parent company Québecor. When the workers were locked out they began to publish their own newspaper, Media Matin Québec, and they eventually launched an online version. As of today the online version is still operating.



Why did Molly describe this initiative as "hopeful" ? First of all because it went beyond the usual round of tactics that happen during most strikes and lockouts into the sort of moves that Molly considers to be necessary preliminaries to the building of the sort of libertarian socialism that she favours. What was proven was that the workers at Le Journal de Québec could do the work of producing and distributing a newspaper without the direction of the bosses. If there is to be any real socialism it has to be a socialism that not only has no private owners but much more importantly has no managers as well. The workers at Le Journal proved it could be done. It is true that the paper produced by these workers was considerably less "weighty" than the Le Journal that management continued to produce during the lockout with the help of scab labour. The "means of production" are, after all, the "means of production", but the efforts of these people showed that it is indeed possible to set up an alternative even without the ultimately more effective tactic of plant occupations and resuming production during the occupation.



The contrast between the "somewhat" successful alternative that the workers produced and what they could have done if they had occupied the workplace also points the way to what should be done in future disputes. As Molly has expressed ad nauseum on this blog her approach to anarchism/libertarian socialism is gradualist. It holds much room for the initiation of producers' coops from scratch, but all such initiatives are, of necessity, small scale. It also holds a lot of room for buyouts of firms using pension funds and such that would turn private firms into workers' cooperatives. The tactic of occupying workplaces and resuming production during the occupation could be a very good bargaining tool for workers to gain ownership of their own working lives. To put it at its crudest, the price goes down when the person you are bargaining with holds a bigger gun than you do. Companies unwilling to sell at anything resembling a reasonable price may see reason when the workplace is occupied and merrily chugging away without their control. Sometimes, when conditions of public support are sufficient the price may go down to zero dollars and zero cents. Yes, it can happen !! It all depends on political conditions amongst the population.



Such occupations would also be the method whereby state owned enterprises would be converted to real socialist workplaces, with a blend of worker and community control. Such a "

long march" requires vision, and the socialists who are willing to agitate, organize and educate for it over the course of decades. A long term interplay that would gradually make such occupations an accepted fact and then gradually introduce resolutions other than minor concessions on the part of the employers or better buyouts in the situation here plants are closing has at least a chance of producing a free society. The history of "revolutions" in the past century and a half has consistently shown that such a path produces no such thing. It is also a way whereby large segments of the economy could be gradually brought into the cooperative/socialist sector as opposed to the almost trivial startups of new and tiny coops. Once a cooperative/socialist sector with real financial clout was established the process would accelerate as the existing coops with resources would be able to effectively support new initiatives.



All of this precludes any militaristic fantasies of "violent revolution". Violence would undoubtedly occur during this transition when the ruling class (usually managers rather than owners) could prevail upon their drinking buddies down at the local elite clubs to send in the police. The political cost of such actions, however, could be made progressively more prohibitive by the gradual education of the population by anarchist/cooperative/socialist organizations willing to do the dirty work of long term organization and what should be an almost automatic reflex action on the part of workers involved in such disputes to make immediate and strenuous efforts to swing the local community (and beyond when needed) to their side.



Another thing that was shown by the workers of Le Journal was that decisions can be undertaken democratically- without management directions. If we are to produce a socialism worthy of the name the class power of the managers has to be addressed. Any new enterprises have to be as thoroughly democratic as possible. It would be an useless expenditure of energy to produce a sea of coops that basically reproduce the managerial ruling class of present state (and most corporate) enterprise. That can, unfortunately, happen, especially if the socialists/communalists/anarchists are blind to the viper in their midst, if they are deluded as to the nature of our present class society-managerial in Molly's opinion- and fail to set up barriers to its reproduction in the new institutions they build.



Pheew! That was a long rant. Anyways, here's the article from CUPE that began this tirade. It should be noted that, whatever the state of this tentative agreement Media Matin Québec continues to publish as of today. I personally hope it will continue.

.......................................

Settlement at Journal de Québec
CUPE members at le Journal de Québec have voted 96 per cent in favour of a tentative agreement reached late last night with Québecor.

Leadership of the three locals involved in the 438 day work stoppage had recommended their members vote for the deal.

The agreement ends the longest contract dispute ever at a french-language daily in Canada.
The tentative agreement was reached at 1am, July 2 after a 24 hour, high-level negotiating session.
Some highlights:

*Agreement goes for five years from signing date
*2.5 per cent per year salary increases
*Classified ad services brought back to Québec City (from Kanata)
*37.5 hour, four day work week (37.5 hours over five days for classified ad employees)
*One more week of vacation for temporary employees with more than 10 years service (Molly Note- "temporary employees" with "more than 10 !!!!! years of service" ????)
*Introduce a floor for the number of journalists and photographers to maintain local coverage while allowing multimedia
*Changes to press room work rules in exchange for investment in new equipment
*Early retirement program: four weeks salary per year of service up to 18 months
*Possibility of jobs at Vidéotron for affected office employees

About 280 employees of the Québec City tabloid have been on strike or locked out since April 22, 2007, the first work stoppage to hit the paper since it started in 1967.

Thursday, July 03, 2008


CANADIAN ANARCHIST MOVEMENT/MOUVEMENT ANARCHISTE DU CANADA:
ARE WE REALLY 10% OF THE POPULATION ?:
Yesterday's celebrations of the 400th anniversary of the founding of Québec City passed in soaking rain in Québec City itself. It was observed with bell ringings from coast to coast, including here in Winnipeg where the media had the bizarre idea that Champlain got as far west as here and crossed the Red River. I really have to look this up, but I doubt it seriously. in any case they held some sort of re-enactment here today while the bells of St. Boniface Cathedral rang out as they did across the country. Strange !
In Québec City itself, according to Media Matin Québec , soon unfortunately no longer be in this world the crowds that gathered in the rain to watch the official bullshit numbered about 5,000 to 6,000 while the number of anti-militarist militants who protested the events (previously announced here at Molly's Blog) were about 500 in number. According to Media Matin Québec there were two arrests during the course of the demonstrations.
Molly hopes to present further news in the morning, including, hopefully, reports from our own Québec comrades. I also hope to present both the French language version and the story of the probable end of Media Matin Québec, one of the most hopeful labour initiatives on the North American continent. Maybe it will continue. I certainly hope so. But until then I leave the reader with the numerical puzzle given above. Do we really represent 10% of the population, at least in the province of Québec ? I don't think so, but wouldn't it be great if it was true ?

CANADIAN POLITICS:
HOORAY FOR HENRY: HENRY MORGENTALER NAMED TO ORDER OF CANADA:
The recent news is that Henry Morgentaler, long time provider and campaigner for the right of Canadian women to access abortion, has finally, at the age age of 85 been named to the Order of Canada. The OOC is an award given from the office of the Governor General for outstanding contribution to the well-being of Canadian society, and there is little doubt that Morgentaler deserves this ward as few individuals have had such a profound civilizing effect as he has had over the years. Predictably our Conservative federal government lost no time in distancing itself from the nomination, pointing out that the selection is made by a committee totally seperate from the government of the day. Ooops ! Looks like this was one more thing that Sneaky Stevie forgot to get under his sweaty little thumb. Look towards underhanded conspiracies to stack the GG's committee in the future. But true to Sneaky Stevie's iron rule of his own caucus Conservative MPs were provided with a prepared script from which they were to read when questioned on the matter. can't let some of the nutters in his party slip up, and produce yet another scandal. There's all sorts of such potential in this situation.
The reaction of anti-abortion forces in both the Catholic Church and evangelical right wingers was far less measured than that of the government. Ballistic would be an understatement. The "shame" ! The "degradation" ! The 'horror" ! The "degeneracy" ! The who knows how many other dozen epithets that filled the media in the last few days. Some of this approaches Monty Python levels. One Catholic priest, Lucien Larre of Coquitlam B.C, has theatrically returned the Order of Canada medal that he received in 1983 for "his work with emotionally disturbed and addicted youth". Full stop here kiddies. One wonders exactly how many of the young people who were "helped" by Fr. Larre were in his clutches on a voluntary basis. The word "none" is a plausible answer. In 1992 Fr. Larre was convicted on two counts of assault on residents in one of his youth "homes" (can we say the words "juvenile prison" ?). One girl was slapped and choked by this loving example of Christian charity. The other was force fed pills that this "saintly" individual determined that she should take even if they had to be rammed down her throat. Both were indictable offenses, but, of course, Larre served no prison time. Still, it was no considered "degrading" to the OOC that what would be called in the USA "a convicted felon" continued to hold the Order. Larre didn't resign then, but rather waited until man who was acquitted by three different juries over the years was awarded same.
Lucien Larre is hardly the only convicted criminal who has retained his Order of Canada. the infamous Conrad Black, now serving time for massive corporate fraud in an US jail, is the subject of an ongoing online petition to have him removed from the lists of the Order. This case is particularly apt as Black renounced his Canadian citizenship in order to be appointed to the British House of Lords (Lord Black of the Brady Road Landfill it should have been). He is now trying to slither back to a Canadian prison in hopes of serving both easier and less time. Being a Canadian looks a little more attractive when you are wearing a prison jumpsuit rather than a red ermine robe.
The award is, after all, supposed to be a Canadian award. While nowhere approaching the level of both arrogance and criminality of Conrad Black, the case of ex-Prime Minister Kim Campbell is also instructive. Her "loyalty" to this country has been amply demonstrated by the fact that since losing power she has decided to reside elsewhere, first in Los Angeles and more recently in France. She did, admittedly, sneak back in to view the unveiling of her picture in the halls of the Parliament Building, but she promptly left again to climes that she feels are more congenial than that of the country that gave her this award. One can be assured that if Kimmy ever gets tattoos there will be an American Eagle on one buttock and a Fleur de Lis on the other. The placement of the Maple Leaf, if it appears at all I'll leave to your imagination. Yes, this is a Canadian award ????
But enough of these unpleasant individuals. Let's return to Henry Morgentaler. There are few people on earth that Molly will apply the description "heroic" to, and Henry Morgentaler is one of them. he was born in 1923 in Lodz, Poland. When the Germans captured Poland his father Josef Morgentaler was captured and killed by the Gestapo. He was not only a Jew but was also a member of the Jewish Socialist Labour Bund. Henry himself was finally sent to Auschwitz in 1944, but he survived. At the time of Liberation he weighed all of 70 pounds (he was 22 years of age). He took his medical studies under an United Nations scholarship program. upon graduation he refused to emigrate to Israel because he opposed Zionism, and in 1950 he and his wife emigrated to Canada instead. He then practiced general medicine in Montreal for the next two decades.
Morgentaler's convictions about the right of women to an abortion gradually drew him away from general medical practice. In 1967 he first testified in front of a government committee about this issue, and in 1969 he left his family practice to open an abortion clinic. The next decades were ones of legal struggle as charges were repeatedly laid against Dr. Morgentaler, and he was repeatedly acquitted by juries who refused to convict him despite the fact that he fully admitted that he broke the letter of the law. As an aside Morgentaler's legal struggles may have solidified a principle of Canadian society that is at least as important as his 1988 victory that ended all statutory restrictions on abortion in Canada. This principle was discussed here at Molly's Blog in connection with the case of Robert Latimer, and it resulted in the longest exchange of comments that this blog has seen. The principle is that of "jury supremacy" or "jury nullification". It is the accepted principle in Common Law that the decision of a jury is supreme, that it cannot be overruled by the judiciary. The final result was what has been called the 'Morgentaler Amendment' to the Criminal Code that forbade the overturn of a jury acquittal by a higher court of judges. The importance of this right of ordinary citizens cannot be overestimated. The right of women to control their own bodies, free from interference from the State, is one particular case. It was established by the exercise of their right of supremacy by three juries, a legal precedent that has far greater implications than one particular right. This right, which is "hated" (this is not too strong a word !) by both the legal establishment and by reactionaries of both the left and right, says that a committee of ordinary citizens, embodied in a jury, has the supreme right to judge a case on the basis of fundamental justice no matter what the letter of the law says. This is a safeguard against tyranny, and a door through which social progress can enter. If the reader wants to read the long exchange on this matter here on this blog just search "Robert Latimer" on Molly's Blog.
To read more about Henry Morgentaler, his life, work and struggles go to the link on him above. You may also want to consult the Wikipedia article Abortion in Canada for further information. But, as a famous American once said, "the price of liberty is eternal vigilance". Just as both the legal establishment and reactionaries are forever campaigning to reduce the fundamental right of jury supremacy, and, if they can't abolish it, hem it in as much as possible to reduce its effectiveness so too those who oppose women's right to choose will continue to try and abolish this mark of civilization. Our present Conservative government, under the able thumb of Sneaky Stevie will, of course, make no such noises as long as it is in a minority position, but let them win a majority and trial balloons will follow soon after. Canadian society will continue to hold those who are opposed to this right for the foreseeable future.
But they are not without opposition. Here are a few links to Canadian organizations that are devoted to keeping us on the list of civilized nations on this matter:
and, of course, the Morgentaler Clinic itself